California Prune and Apricot Growers

From Packing Houses of Santa Clara County
Jump to: navigation, search
Summary
Business

Dried Fruit Packer,Cooperative
Main Location

San Jose, CA
Active

1917 - present
Aliases

Sunsweet, Growers Packing and Warehousing Association
Predecessors

Campbell Farmer's Union Packing Company
Sunsweet logo, 1920's
Sunsweet Plant #11, San Jose (Former A&C Ham). From 1920 ad.

The California Prune and Apricot Growers (commonly known as Sunsweet) is a long-lived co-operative for prune and apricot growers. Founded in San Jose in 1917, the company adapted to changes in marketing and in the locations of the crops. The company has also handled prune and apricot-related products, including canned prunes[1], prune juice, and apricot pit oil[2]. The company is currently based in Yuba City.

The association was started in the spring of 1917. Early management included Frank Coykendall (who sold his Andrews and Coykendall Ham Company to avoid conflicts of interest) and office manager Samuel Squibb[3] (who later worked for the George E. Hyde & Company in Campbell.

The co-operative initially served only for negotiating and marketing, but relied on independent packers to actually handle the crop. For the 1917 season, the association got commitments from farmers producing 75% of that year’s crop. Forty-five packers around the state were signed up to actually handle the crop. The San Jose list includes many of the smaller dried fruit packers[4]:

…east side growers

to George Frank Fruit Company on Alum Rock, south of San Jose to O.A. Harlan on South 4th, Campbell to George Hyde & Co, Los Gatos and vicinity to Curtis Fruit, Los Gatos; Saratoga, San Tomas, and growers around Vasona to Gem City Packing, Vasona; Mountain View and growers north of Fremont Avenue including Los Altos and Mountain View to Mountain View Packing Company; Mountain View, growers south of Fremont (Ave) and others go to George Herbert on Lincoln, F.H. Holmes on 18th and Jackson, J.W Chilton on North First, Pacific Fruit Products on San Carlos Street, J.B. Inderrieden, Ryland Street, Warren Dried Fruit, Ryland Street, A & C Ham, Cinnabar Street, San Jose.

Even with their large fraction of the California fruit crop, he association only sold about 47% of the total crop either because of cancelled memberships or growers secretly selling to packers.

The packers working with Sunsweet that year formed their own organization called the Affiliated Packers[5].

Working with the independent packers also turned out to be challenging from a business standpoint. Packing costs varied wildly by packing house. In some cases, packers either delayed paying the association for fruit sold or underestimated the crop owned by the association. In the most obvious case, the George N. Herbert Packing Company supposedly sold a million pounds of the crop without informing the association and held on to the $100,000 in proceeds, leading to a lawsuit, a demand for a $320,000 bond, and a louder demand for the immediate return of 1.9 million pounds of prunes and 178,000 pounds of apricots which belonged to Sunsweet. "...Mr Herbert gave copies of the shipping sheets to the inspectors, so as to permit the fruit to be checked out of the packing plant, but sent only a few selected sheets thereof to the sales department so that the officers of the corporation would be unable to find out that he was liable to the corporation for the purchase of the fruit."[6]. Sunsweet grabbed the twenty-two carloads of packed fruit and 200 tons of prunes the next week[7]. As a result, the association began to make offers to buy dried fruit packing houses so they could control their own crop[8]. The company also planned to manage the selling of apricot pits[9]Sunsweet acquired 16 packing houses before the beginning of the 1918 crop[10], first one bought was the George N. Herbert Packing Company plant.

The association also created their own “field warehouses” to hold onto packed but not-yet-sold fruit. Field warehousing put the product in the hands of a separate company on paper. By having a separate public warehousing company issue warehouse receipts, the association could then borrow money against the stored fruit [11]. Sunsweet’s field warehousing subsidiary was the Growers Packing and Warehouse Association.

Relations were mixed with the independent packers and brokers who had previously controlled the crops. At its inception, E. N. Richmond was quoted as saying that the brokers won't try to break the prices of the growers association[12]. In 1928, the association explicitly told packers they wouldn't tolerate encouraging growers to break contracts[13]. The World War also gave cover, because the U.S. department managing food was attempting to control prices by banning fruit buyers from soliciting someone who had already signed a contract[14]. The company was also challenged by lower prices for European fruit. Frank Coykendall summarized the market and Bosnian prunes in the February 1923 Western Canner and Packer

Sunsweet also attempted to control the price by keeping smaller and off-grade fruit off the market. During the 1918 season, they announced that smaller fruit would not be dried, but would be instead turned into "Mar-jam", the company's cross between marmalade and jam. The former O. A. Harlan packing house at 4th and Lewis was used for by-products including jam-making[15].

Sunsweet representatives also covered areas further away from their packing houses. During the 1929 season, the company representatives came to Hayward to encourage growers to hold out for higher prices[16]

Sunsweet may have also had rebellions from within. In 1925, a group of growers in Healdsburg considered forming a separate organization. The growers were angered by Sonoma county prunes being billed as from the "Santa Clara Valley"[17].

Locations

The following locations were believed to be operated by Sunsweet. Several other plants were leased but never bought, including Plant 22 (George E. Hyde & Company, Campbell), Plant 37 (Warren E. Hyde and S. E. Johnson, Cupertino), and Plant 38 (West Side Fruit Growers Association, Stevens Creek Road, Cupertino).

Location Plant Number Years Address Details
Brooklyn, NY Plant 43 1921-1922 Bush Terminal Docks[18]
Campbell Plant 1 1917, 1964 5 Central Avenue Former Campbell Farmer's Union Packing Company.
Colusa 1922 Construction started in 1922[19][20].
Cupertino Plant 38 Stevens Creek Road West Side Fruit Growers Association. Contract packer only?
Dinuba 1922, 1934 265 North N St. (Now N. Urapan Way)[21] July 1922 Western Canner and Packer. L. C. Wallace was manager in 1934.
Geyserville 18521 Fredson Road.[22] Supposedly receiving station, previously owned by Sherriffs Brothers. Now used by Fredson Winery.
Gilroy Plant 3 1917 - Former Gilroy Farmer's Union. In operation at least to 1958. Partial photo shows three story wood frame building[23].
Healdsburg Plant 31[24] 1922 "South side of town near railroad tracks"[25] Former Sherriffs Brothers plant. Bought in 1922[26].
Healdsburg - 1970 33 Healdsburg Ave Modern. Included mechanical dryer. Became Fairchild Semiconductor[27]
Hemet Plant 5 1917- East Devonshire Ave. at N. Harvard Street. Former Hemet Apricot Grower's Association[28]. Still exists.
Hollister Plant 9 1917- Former Hollister Packing Company.
Los Gatos Plant 7 1917-1928 Winchester Road Former Gem City Packing Company. Became Sewall_Brown_and_Company
Los Gatos Plant 13 1917  ???
Los Gatos 1923 538 University Ave.[29]
Morgan Hill Plant 2 1917-1964 91 East 4th Street Former Morgan Hill Farmer's Union . Torn down 1964. Dryer in town until 1987[30].
Mountain View Plant 8 1917- 1921 Oak Street at Villa St. Former Mountain View Packing Company.
Napa 1922-? 849 Jackson St.[31]</ref>[32][33] Exists, damaged in 2014 Napa earthquake.
Red Bluff 1922- Bought from Sanitary Fruit Company in 1922 according to July 1922 Western Canner and Packer.
San Jose 213 W. Santa Clara Street Public fruit market,
San Jose Plant 4 1921, 1926- 4th and Lewis Used for the "special carton trade"[34].
San Jose Plant 6 595 Lincoln Ave. Former George N. Herbert Packing Company. Replaced by Contadina warehouse by 1959[35].
San Jose Plant 10 1964 2670 Alum Rock Ave. Alum Rock at White. Former George Frank and Company plant. San Jose Railroads (trolley) built extension to plant in 1922[36].
San Jose Plant 10 Meridian Road at narrow gauge Former George Frank and Company.
San Jose Plant 11 1921, 1936, ~1960 570 Cinnabar Former Andrews and Coykendall Ham Company. built 1918. Demolished by 1966[37].
San Jose Plant 12 1917 8th and Jackson St. Former F. H. Holmes. Immediately sold to Greco Canning?[38][39]
San Jose Plant 14 1922 405 North First Former Chilton plant. Bought in June 1922[40]
San Jose Plant 15 1917 Ryland St. Former J. B. Inderrieden.
San Jose Plant 16 1922 740 W. San Carlos Street Bought in September 1922 from Pacific Fruit Products[41].
San Jose Plant 17 1918-? Margaret and 4th Former O. A. Harlan & Company.
San Jose Plant 7 1964 7th and Alma[42].
San Jose 1964 Market and San Fernando. Headquarters.
Santa Paula 1922 Apricot processing plant[43].
Santa Rosa 1922- Wright Ave.[44] Receiving station, either former former Sherriffs Brothers plant or contract station run by M.L. McDonald. Lasted "a while" after 1920.
Sunnyvale Plant 41 1923, 1930 Evelyn St. at Central Ave.[45][46]
Visalia 1934 602 S. Bridge St. Building still exists. Manager in 1934 was R. J. Scheline[47]. Yuba City 1964 Enlarged 1964.

Photos

Sunsweet Campbell Co-operative Dryer, 1960's. At San Jose State.

Hemet: Photo at [3]. Plant is listed there as Growers Packing and Warehousing #5.

Additional photos of Sunsweet Plants appear in advertisement October 30, 1920.

Photo of man shoveling prunes in Sherriffs Brothers packing house, Healdsburg.[48]

Geyserville Exterior View of the Sunsweet Prune Packing Plant. From Sonoma County Library.

Sunsweet Plant #10, San Jose (former George Frank and Company plant): History San Jose.

Sunsweet in Mountain View

1921 Sanborn map shows main building has storage on first and second floors, grading on third, and a "process room" (sulfuring?) on second floor. Separate warehouse. Separate boiler house, with oil tanks at ground level. (Not on rolls by 1921)

Sunsweet in San Jose

Sunsweet had several plants in San Jose, ranging from primitive and small to modern and large.

Bob Morris photos from early 1960's show the Mission-style tower and shed roof of the former Andrews and Coykendall Ham Company. The plant was built in 1917 as three-story, concrete. 1950 Sanborn map shows used for grading and packing.

Two story concrete building with grader on 2nd floor and warehouse on first. Built for O.C. Harlan in 1918. Separate sulfur house.

Plant 14, the former J. W. Chilton Fruit Packing Plant, was bought by the association in 1922 and used for their "special carton trade"[49]. The engineer at the plant for some years was Frank Frymire, who had previously worked for O. A. Harlan[50].

Sunsweet in Sunnyvale

References

  1. Association's Opening Prices on Crop 1922 Canned Prunes: July 1922 Western Canner and Packer
  2. Prunes: January 1923 Western Canner and Packer. Attempt to manufacture cooking oil from prune and apricot kernels. Sunsweet calling it "Sunsweet Nut-Oil".
  3. All Goes Well With Growers: May 21, 1917 San Jose News
  4. July 21, 1917 San Jose Evening News
  5. Prune Packers Unite: June 9, 1917 California Fruit News.
  6. Packers Fear More Suits for Contract Breach Following Herbert Litigation: November 27, 1917 San Jose Mercury Herald
  7. Quantity of Prunes Seized at Local Packing House by the Growers' Association: December 5, 1917 San Jose Mercury Herald
  8. Field Crops: May 11, 1918 Pacific Rural Press: CPGA was buying packing houses in the large growing areas, not just leasing or otherwise combining.
  9. Field Crops: May 11, 1918 Pacific Rural Press: “The Prune and Apricot Growers' Association has developed a market for their apricot pits whereby members will receive better than $31.50 per ton for them. The contract is for two years, with privilege of a two-year extension.”
  10. California Dried Fruit Packing Houses: June 1918 Western Canner and Packer: Gem City being converted to handle pits only, eighteen plants officially being labeled “Sunsweet plants”.
  11. Procedure of Extending Credit on Canned Food in Warehouses: March 1923 Western Canner and Packer.
  12. May 21, 1917 San Jose Evening News
  13. Association Warns Packers to Sue if Growers Lured: July 27, 1928 San Jose Evening News.
  14. Forbid Soliciting Association Fruit. July 30, 1918 San Jose Evening News. "The ... association is convinced a number of packers have been soliciting for contracts with growers who are members of the organization". They warned that the U.S. food administration explicitly required solicitors to see whether the fruit had been promised elsewhere.
  15. Small-sized Fruit Will Be Used: July 30, 1918 San Jose Evening News.
  16. 'Cot Men Begin Drive To Obtain Higher Prices: Delay In Fruit Sales Pending Improvement Is Voted. June 28, 1929 Hayward Review. "The meeting was one of 15 or 20 similar sessions held throughout the California apricot districts, under the auspices of the California Prune and Apricot Growers association, as the preliminary campaign moves. Canners had offered $50/ton for apricots last season, but 1929 offered higher prices only for the largest apricots.
  17. Sonoma Fruit Men in Move To Form New Association. October 23, 1925 San Jose Evening News.
  18. Robert Couchman, The Sunsweet Story, Sunsweet, 1967. Closed within a year - packing costs were four times what they were in California.
  19. Cannery News: February 1922 Canning Age
  20. July 1922 Western Canner and Packer
  21. 1934 Visalia City Directory
  22. Exterior of Sunsweet Prune Packing Plant, Geyserville Ca ca. 1910. In Wine Photography collection of Sonoma County Library.
  23. Kenneth G. Johnson, Pacific: 2472's Family Album. Interurban Press, 1990. P. 54.
  24. Agricultural Cooperative Organizations in California, 1937. Also lists many of the associations affiliated with Sunsweet.
  25. Healdsburg Museum, [1]. Arcadia Publishing, 2005.
  26. March 1922 Canning Age.
  27. Sunsweet Building photo. Sonoma County Library Photo Collection.
  28. Photo: Packing Houses of Southern California. Listed as Growers Packing and Warehousing Association
  29. 1923 Los Gatos City Directory
  30. August 7, 1987 San Jose Mercury News
  31. The Prunes Are Gone, But Sunsweet Dehydrator Has Second Life. October 7, 2010 Napa Valley Register.
  32. July 1922 Western Canner and Packer
  33. February 1922 Canning Age”. Construction to begin in spring.
  34. 1922 Western Canner and Packer. Plant was too small, so they bought the J. W. Chilton plant at 405 North First Street. Leased to Libby for one season.
  35. San Jose Building Permit 1959-029819-000-BD: build 1 story warehouse for Contadina Foods, estimated value $100,000.
  36. Charles S. McCaleb, "Tracks, Trains, and Wires: Public Transportation in California's Santa Clara Valley". Interurban Press, Glendale CA, 1981. "On October 7, 1922... the San Jose Railroads asked the city for rights to haul freight at night over the Seventeenth Street line, a former privilege. The immediate purpose was to serve the California Prune and Apricot Growers' plant at Alum Rock and Capitol Avenues. The city turned down the application. So the Peninsular asked rights from the city and county to build a new single-track passenger and freight line up King Road north from Alum Rock to Berryessa Road, where it would join with the existing Berryessa line. San Jose gave its approval March 26, 1923. The county followed suit April 2. Crews then installed rails along the east side of King Road from Alum Rock Avenue to McKee Road, crossing over to the west side from McKee to Berryessa Road. On July 18 the Railroad Commission gave the Peninsular a certificate of authority to operate the new route."
  37. San Jose Building Permit: 1966-049055-000-BD. For demolition of site, former industrial, now vacant lot.
  38. Growers To Buy Up Nine Local Packers: April 10, 1918 San Jose Mercury Herald
  39. Prune Association Buys First Plant: June 6, 1918 San Jose Evening News. "The association will soon take over the Holmes plant, and will probably sell it to the Greco company to use as a cannery, as the association does not need it, but according to the agreement with the packers, has to take it over."
  40. July 1922 Western Canner and Packer.
  41. September 1922 Western Canner and Packer.
  42. Referenced in Portuguese in San Jose, Arcadia Publishing.
  43. November 1922 Western Canner and Packer. Handled 1,700 tons in 1921, expecting 3,500 tons in 1922.
  44. George Greeott letter, Gaye LeBaron Digital Collection, North Bay Digital Collections.
  45. 1930 Sanborn Fire Insurance Map.
  46. January 1923 Western Canner and Packer
  47. 1934 Visalia City Directory
  48. Healdsburg Museum, [2]. Arcadia Publishing, 2005.
  49. July 1922 Western Canner and Packer.
  50. Frymire Last Rites Planned: May 9, 1932 San Jose Evening News