Difference between revisions of "Earl Fruit Company"

Summary
Business	Dried Fruit Packer,Fresh Fruit Packer
Successors	Armour and Company, Di Giorgio Fruit Company

Latest revision as of 17:56, 17 January 2017

The Earl Fruit Company was a California-based fruit and vegetable packer and wholesaler. The company handled fresh and dried fruit, and also handled vegetables. Although a pioneer in shipping fruit, the company was sold to Armour and Company in 1900. In 1911, the Supreme Court forced the meat packers to divest their refrigerator cars because of their monopoly power. Joseph Di Giorgio of the Di Giorgio fruit brokerage business in Baltimore bought Earl Fruit from Armour for access to the fresh fruit market^[1].

Earl Fruit was founded by Edwin Tobias Earl, a prominent fruit shipper in California. Earl was also an early proponent of shipping fruit east from California. The company often charged for packing but let the grower get the risk or reward from the fruit sale. "Growers would bring in their fruit, and Earl would manufacture the boxes and sell them to the grower and pack and sort the fruit, and then ship it for the account of the grower and charge them for the freight in each refrigerated car in addition to the freight charged by the railroad for transportation. So it was a very, very lucrative business for the Armour family."^[2] In 1901, the company provided all supplies and advanced money to Chinese farmers in the Los Angeles area to raise celery ^[3]

The company's fruit was shipped both across the United States and to Europe under its Red Flag trademark^[4]. In 1903, pears, peaches, and plums were being shipped from San Jose to Australia^[5]. In 1893, the company shipped 4,000 carloads of fruit^[6].

An 1897 photo of an orange packing house in Redlands, California states the company's presence in Chicago, Boston, New York, and Philadelphia^[7].

Earl Fruit and Armour

The Earl Fruit Company was closely tied with the Armour meat interests, both as an ally and competitor. In 1888, the California Fruit Transportation Company started shipping chilled fruit via refrigerator cars. Earl initially worked with C.F.T.C., providing 75% of their traffic out of California. In 1892, Earl appeared in Chicago and demanded a discount or commission for the business he directed to them. When the C.F.T.C. officers turned him down, Earl "went straight to the office of the Armour Car Line. Before the end of the day he had contracted to rent 1,000 Armour refrigerator cars at $8.33 a month each. When the California fruit season reopened, the C.F.T. found that wherever it went, the Earl Fruit Company was there also, making war and using an familiar and effective weapon; that is to say, it was offering rebates and getting the fruit."^[8] Earl Fruit attempted to work with the new company because of its strong presence in the California packing market. When talks broke off, Earl instead contacted the Armour company about using their refrigerator cars, and organized a pair of refrigerated car lines for his own use^[9]. Backed by Armour, Earl dominated the refrigerated fruit transportation business. (The competitors, meanwhile, sold out to Swift and Company. Armour later backed Porter Brothers, forcing Earl to sell out to Armour in 1900. By 1903, Armour had taken control of Earl Fruit, with Earl keeping a minor ownership role^[10]. Earl took his profits from his fruit shipping empire, built a large mansion on Wilshire Boulevard in Los Angeles, and started a new career as publisher of the Los Angeles Express newspaper^[11].

Locations

Location	Years	Address	Details
Locke		River Road	Rented space in Southern Pacific warehouse^[12].
Lodi
Newcastle	1915		In freight shed along railroad^[13].
Placerville	1910	Spring Street at Lincoln Highway.	Placerville. 1910 Sanborn fire insurance map.
Redlands	1897		100 x 160 foot packing house for oranges^[14]
Sacramento	1908	1014 Second Street	Head office^[15].
San Jose	1892, 1900	Bassett near San Pedro
San Jose	1893, 1896, 1902, 1906, 1907	Bassett Street at Terraine Street	Northeast Corner.
San Jose	1936, 1938	395a North First Street
Winters	1951	Abbay St., across tracks from depot.^[16]
Wright	1911	On Sunset Park spur (now Wrights Station Road), on north side of road on north side of creek, east of road bridge.

Photos

Earl Fruit Company, Walnut Grove California State Library, California History Section

References

↑ Ruth Teiser, Robert Di Giorgio and Joseph A. Di Giorgio: The Di Giorgio's: From Fruit Merchants to Corporate Innovators". Oral history, Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley, 1983.
↑ Ruth Teiser, Robert Di Giorgio and Joseph A. Di Giorgio: The Di Giorgio's: From Fruit Merchants to Corporate Innovators". Oral history, Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley, 1983. "The Earl Fruit Company was headed up by a man named E. T. Earl from Sacramento, who owned a small portion of it and who was the manager of a company for the Armour family."
↑ George W. Moore, History of the Celery Industry. In Samuel Armor, History of Orange County, California, with Biographical Sketches. Historic Record Company, 1921. "(In 1901...) Mr. [E. A.] Curtis bethought himself of the Los Angeles Chinese market gardeners and their knowledge of celery growing, and at once entered into negotiations with a leading Chinaman to undertake the work of growing eighty acres of celery on contract, the Earl Fruit Company to furnish everything, including implements needed in the cultivation of the crop, also money advanced for rental of the land and the supplying of water where needed by digging wells..."
↑ The Earl Fruit Company: Leading Fruit Shippers.. November 26, 1908 Sacramento Union.
↑ Our Fruits Find Favor in Markets of the Workd. August 29, 1903 San Jose Evening News.
↑ The Fruit Shipping Industry. In Sacramento County and Its Resources. JH. McClatchy and Company, 1895.
↑ Earl Fruit Company. In Illustrated Redlands, 1897.
↑ Charles Edward Russell, The Greatest Trust in the World. Part 1: The Great Yellow Car: the Bandit of Commerce.". March 1905 Everybody's Magazine.
↑ Ray Stannard Baker, Railroads on Trial: Private Cars and the Fruit Industry (part 4). February 1906 McClure's Magazine.
↑ Failure: Porter Brothers Company Forced to the Wall Earl's second major competitor, meanwhile was forced into bankruptcy. In May 23, 1903 Fruit Trade Journal and Produce Record. "It was reported in San Francisco that the failure was due to Armour, who recently gained control of the Earl Fruit Company. Armour has an ambition to monopoloize the shipping of California fruit" says the dispatch.".
↑ 2425 Wilshire Blvd. Historic Los Angeles: When Wilshire Boulevard Was Residential. Earl's mansion was designed by San Francisco architect Ernest Coxhead in 1897. Article also contains a short biography of Earl.
↑ The Community of Locke. Walking tour. Walnutgrove.com.
↑ Earl Fruit Packing Company. Sacramento History Online. Producer's Fruit is next door, which apparently was another Di Giorgio business.
↑ Earl Fruit Company. In Illustrated Redlands, 1897.
↑ The Earl Fruit Company: Leading Fruit Shippers.. November 26, 1908 Sacramento Union.
↑ Winters: Retire Packing Shed. Southern Pacific Western Division Drawing W-1814, August 7, 1951. In collection at wx4.org.

[1] Ruth Teiser, Robert Di Giorgio and Joseph A. Di Giorgio: The Di Giorgio's: From Fruit Merchants to Corporate Innovators". Oral history, Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley, 1983.

[2] Ruth Teiser, Robert Di Giorgio and Joseph A. Di Giorgio: The Di Giorgio's: From Fruit Merchants to Corporate Innovators". Oral history, Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley, 1983. "The Earl Fruit Company was headed up by a man named E. T. Earl from Sacramento, who owned a small portion of it and who was the manager of a company for the Armour family."

[3] George W. Moore, History of the Celery Industry. In Samuel Armor, History of Orange County, California, with Biographical Sketches. Historic Record Company, 1921. "(In 1901...) Mr. [E. A.] Curtis bethought himself of the Los Angeles Chinese market gardeners and their knowledge of celery growing, and at once entered into negotiations with a leading Chinaman to undertake the work of growing eighty acres of celery on contract, the Earl Fruit Company to furnish everything, including implements needed in the cultivation of the crop, also money advanced for rental of the land and the supplying of water where needed by digging wells..."

[4] The Earl Fruit Company: Leading Fruit Shippers.. November 26, 1908 Sacramento Union.

[5] Our Fruits Find Favor in Markets of the Workd. August 29, 1903 San Jose Evening News.

[6] The Fruit Shipping Industry. In Sacramento County and Its Resources. JH. McClatchy and Company, 1895.

[7] Earl Fruit Company. In Illustrated Redlands, 1897.

[8] Charles Edward Russell, The Greatest Trust in the World. Part 1: The Great Yellow Car: the Bandit of Commerce.". March 1905 Everybody's Magazine.

[9] Ray Stannard Baker, Railroads on Trial: Private Cars and the Fruit Industry (part 4). February 1906 McClure's Magazine.

[10] Failure: Porter Brothers Company Forced to the Wall Earl's second major competitor, meanwhile was forced into bankruptcy. In May 23, 1903 Fruit Trade Journal and Produce Record. "It was reported in San Francisco that the failure was due to Armour, who recently gained control of the Earl Fruit Company. Armour has an ambition to monopoloize the shipping of California fruit" says the dispatch.".

[11] 2425 Wilshire Blvd. Historic Los Angeles: When Wilshire Boulevard Was Residential. Earl's mansion was designed by San Francisco architect Ernest Coxhead in 1897. Article also contains a short biography of Earl.

[12] The Community of Locke. Walking tour. Walnutgrove.com.

[13] Earl Fruit Packing Company. Sacramento History Online. Producer's Fruit is next door, which apparently was another Di Giorgio business.

[14] Earl Fruit Company. In Illustrated Redlands, 1897.

[15] The Earl Fruit Company: Leading Fruit Shippers.. November 26, 1908 Sacramento Union.

[16] Winters: Retire Packing Shed. Southern Pacific Western Division Drawing W-1814, August 7, 1951. In collection at wx4.org.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[12]

[13]

[14]

[15]

[16]

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-'''Earl Fruit Company'''
 {{Infobox_Industry
 | primary_business = Dried Fruit Packer,Fresh Fruit Packer
+| primary_years = 1880-1910
+| successors = [[Armour and Company]], [[Di Giorgio Fruit Company]]
 }}
+The '''Earl Fruit Company''' was a California-based fruit and vegetable packer and wholesaler.  The company handled fresh and dried fruit, and also handled vegetables.  Although a pioneer in shipping fruit, the company was sold to [[Armour and Company]] in 1900. In 1911, the Supreme Court forced the meat packers to divest their refrigerator cars
+because of their monopoly power. Joseph Di Giorgio of the Di Giorgio
+fruit brokerage business in Baltimore bought Earl Fruit from Armour for access to
+the fresh fruit market<ref>Ruth Teiser, [https://books.google.com/books?id=yhMVAAAAYAAJ&lpg=PA166&ots=zmAUXaBBua&dq=earl%20fruit%20company%20origins&pg=PA166#v=onepage&q=earl%20fruit%20company%20origins&f=false Robert Di Giorgio and Joseph A. Di Giorgio: The Di Giorgio's: From Fruit Merchants to Corporate Innovators"].  Oral history, Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley, 1983.</ref>.
+Earl Fruit was founded by [[Edwin Tobias Earl]], a prominent fruit shipper in California.  Earl was also an early proponent of shipping fruit east from California. The company often charged for packing but let the grower get the risk or reward from the fruit sale.  "Growers would bring in their fruit, and Earl would manufacture the boxes and sell them to the grower and pack and sort the fruit, and then ship it for the account of the grower and charge them for the freight in each refrigerated car in addition to the freight charged by the railroad for transportation.  So it was a very, very lucrative business for the Armour family."<ref>Ruth Teiser, [https://books.google.com/books?id=yhMVAAAAYAAJ&lpg=PA166&ots=zmAUXaBBua&dq=earl%20fruit%20company%20origins&pg=PA166#v=onepage&q=earl%20fruit%20company%20origins&f=false Robert Di Giorgio and Joseph A. Di Giorgio: The Di Giorgio's: From Fruit Merchants to Corporate Innovators"].  Oral history, Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley, 1983.  "The Earl Fruit Company was headed up by a man named E. T. Earl from Sacramento, who owned a small portion of it and who was the manager of a company for the Armour family."</ref>  In 1901, the company provided all supplies and advanced money to Chinese farmers in the Los Angeles area to raise celery
+<ref>George W. Moore, [https://books.google.com/books?id=yhMVAAAAYAAJ&lpg=PA166&ots=zmAUXaBBua&dq=earl%20fruit%20company%20origins&pg=PA166#v=onepage&q=earl%20fruit%20company%20origins&f=false History of the Celery Industry].  In Samuel Armor, History of Orange County, California, with Biographical Sketches.  Historic Record Company, 1921.  "(In 1901...) Mr. [E. A.] Curtis bethought himself of the Los Angeles Chinese market gardeners and their knowledge of celery growing, and at once entered into negotiations with a leading Chinaman to undertake the work of growing eighty acres of celery on contract, the Earl Fruit Company to furnish everything, including implements needed in the cultivation of the crop, also money advanced for rental of the land and the supplying of water where needed by digging wells..."</ref>
+The company's fruit was shipped both across the United States and to Europe under its Red Flag trademark<ref>[https://cdnc.ucr.edu/cgi-bin/cdnc?a=d&d=SU19081126.2.4 The Earl Fruit Company: Leading Fruit Shippers.].  November 26, 1908 Sacramento Union.</ref>.  In 1903, pears, peaches, and plums were being shipped from San Jose to Australia<ref>[http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=6SoiAAAAIBAJ&sjid=QaQFAAAAIBAJ&pg=6087%2C2231066 Our Fruits Find Favor in Markets of the Workd].  August 29, 1903 San Jose Evening News.</ref>.  In 1893, the company shipped 4,000 carloads of fruit<ref>[https://books.google.com/books?id=tBQ1AQAAMAAJ&lpg=PA139&ots=6OemvbBq7-&dq=%22earl%20fruit%20company%22%20sacramento&pg=PA139#v=onepage&q=%22earl%20fruit%20company%22%20sacramento&f=false The Fruit Shipping Industry].  In Sacramento County and Its Resources.  JH. McClatchy and Company, 1895.</ref>.
+An 1897 photo of an orange packing house in Redlands, California states the company's presence in Chicago, Boston, New York, and Philadelphia<ref>[http://www.teachmath.net/Earl%20Family%20Tree/resources/Media_78094956.pdf Earl Fruit Company].  In Illustrated Redlands, 1897.</ref>.
+==Earl Fruit and Armour==
+The Earl Fruit Company was closely tied with the Armour meat interests, both as an ally and competitor.
+In 1888, the [[California Fruit Transportation Company]] started shipping chilled fruit via refrigerator cars.  Earl initially worked with C.F.T.C., providing 75% of their traffic out of California.  In 1892, Earl appeared in Chicago and demanded a discount or commission for the business he directed to them.  When the C.F.T.C. officers turned him down, Earl "went straight to the office of the Armour Car Line. Before the end of the day he had contracted to rent 1,000 Armour refrigerator cars at $8.33 a month each.  When the California fruit season reopened, the C.F.T. found that wherever it went, the Earl Fruit Company was there also, making war and using an familiar and effective weapon; that is to say, it was offering rebates and getting the fruit."<ref>Charles Edward Russell, [https://books.google.com/books?id=l8ZZAAAAYAAJ&lpg=PA298&dq=%22earl%20fruit%22%20armour&pg=PA291#v=onepage&q=%22earl%20fruit%22%20armour&f=false The Greatest Trust in the World].  Part 1: The Great Yellow Car: the Bandit of Commerce.".  March 1905 Everybody's Magazine.</ref>  Earl Fruit attempted to work with the new company because of its strong presence in the California packing market.  When talks broke off, Earl instead contacted the Armour company about using their refrigerator cars, and organized a pair of refrigerated car lines for his own use<ref>Ray Stannard Baker, [https://books.google.com/books?id=59JrxtPVLt8C&lpg=PA400&ots=u4CHQyCS5l&dq=%22earl%20fruit%22%20armour&pg=PA399#v=onepage&q=%22earl%20fruit%22%20armour&f=false Railroads on Trial: Private Cars and the Fruit Industry] (part 4).  February 1906 McClure's Magazine.</ref>.  Backed by Armour, Earl dominated the refrigerated fruit transportation business.  (The competitors, meanwhile, sold out to [[Swift and Company]].  Armour later backed [[Porter Brothers]], forcing Earl to sell out to Armour in 1900.  By 1903, Armour had taken control of Earl Fruit, with Earl keeping a minor ownership role<ref>[https://books.google.com/books?id=AjxKAQAAMAAJ&lpg=PA28-IA10&ots=1U8sMA4JqR&dq=%22porter%20brothers%22%20collapse&pg=PA28-IA10#v=onepage&q=%22porter%20brothers%22%20collapse&f=false Failure: Porter Brothers Company Forced to the Wall]  Earl's second major competitor, meanwhile was forced into bankruptcy.  In May 23, 1903 Fruit Trade Journal and Produce Record. "It was reported in San Francisco that the failure was due to Armour, who recently gained control of the Earl Fruit Company.  Armour has an ambition to monopoloize the shipping of California fruit" says the dispatch.".</ref>.   Earl took his profits from his fruit shipping empire, built a large mansion on Wilshire Boulevard in Los Angeles, and started a new career as publisher of the Los Angeles Express newspaper<ref>[https://wilshireboulevardhouses.blogspot.com/2013/12/2425-wilshire-boulevard-please-see-our.html 2425 Wilshire Blvd.] Historic Los Angeles: When Wilshire Boulevard Was Residential.  Earl's mansion was designed by San Francisco architect Ernest Coxhead in 1897.  Article also contains a short biography of Earl.</ref>.
 ==Locations==
@@ Line 8: / Line 26: @@
 |-
 ! Location !! Years !! Address !! Details
+|-
+| Locke  ||  || River Road || Rented space in Southern Pacific warehouse<ref>[http://www.walnutgrove.com/lockewalk.htm The Community of Locke].  Walking tour.  Walnutgrove.com.</ref>.
+|-
+| Lodi || || ||
+|-
+| Newcastle || 1915 || || In freight shed along railroad<ref>[http://www.sacramentohistory.org/search.php?imageid=1494 Earl Fruit Packing Company].  [http://www.sacramentohistory.org Sacramento History Online].  Producer's Fruit is next door, which apparently was another Di Giorgio business.</ref>.
+|-
+| Placerville || 1910 || Spring Street at Lincoln Highway. || Placerville.  1910 Sanborn fire insurance map.
+|-
+| Redlands || 1897 ||  || 100 x 160 foot packing house for oranges<ref>[http://www.teachmath.net/Earl%20Family%20Tree/resources/Media_78094956.pdf Earl Fruit Company].  In Illustrated Redlands, 1897.</ref>
+|-
+| Sacramento || 1908 || 1014 Second Street || Head office<ref>[https://cdnc.ucr.edu/cgi-bin/cdnc?a=d&d=SU19081126.2.4 The Earl Fruit Company: Leading Fruit Shippers.].  November 26, 1908 Sacramento Union.</ref>.
 |-
 | San Jose || 1892, 1900 || [http://maps.google.com/maps?q=Bassett%20near%20San%20Pedro,San%20Jose Bassett near San Pedro] ||
 |-
 | San Jose || 1893, 1896, 1902, 1906, 1907 || [http://maps.google.com/maps?q=Bassett%20Street%20at%20Terraine%20Street,San%20Jose Bassett Street at Terraine Street] ||
 Northeast Corner.
 |-
 | San Jose || 1936, 1938 || [http://maps.google.com/maps?q=395a%20North%20First%20Street,San%20Jose 395a North First Street] ||
+|-
+| Winters || 1951 || Abbay St., across tracks from depot.<ref>Winters: Retire Packing Shed. Southern Pacific Western Division Drawing W-1814, August 7, 1951.  In collection at [http://wx4.org/to/foam/sp/maps/drawings/sp_drawings-westn.pdf wx4.org].</ref> ||
+|-
+| Wright || 1911 || On Sunset Park spur (now Wrights Station Road), on north side of road on north side of creek, east of road bridge. ||
 |-
 |}
@@ Line 23: / Line 54: @@
 [http://bancroft.library.ca.gov/diglib/image.cfm?id=1150&start=1#1150 Earl Fruit Company, Walnut Grove  California State Library, California History Section]
-[http://memory.loc.gov/cgi-bin/displayPhoto.pl?path=/pnp/habshaer/ca/ca0900/ca0949/photos&topImages=018132pr.jpg&topLinks=018132pv.jpg,018132pu.tif&title=5.  Photocopy of photograph (original print in New Almaden Museum) Circa 1885, photographer unknown WEST FLANK AFTER SECOND ADDITION <br>HABS CAL,43-ALMA,5-5&displayProfile=0 Mine Hill School, Englishtown (with panorama)  Historic American Buildings Survey, Library of Congress]
+==References==
+<references/>
-==Details==
-Started by Edwin Tobias Earl who invented a ventilated refrigerator
-car. Got the Armour company to buy the company. In 1910, the Supreme
-Court forced the meat packers to divest their refrigerator cars
-because of their monopoly power. Joseph Di Giorgio of the Di Giorgio
-fruit brokerage business in Baltimore bought the company for access to
-the fresh fruit market.
-, 1902: Edwin K. Collins is manager. "Packers and shippers of green fruit."
-[http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=6SoiAAAAIBAJ&sjid=QaQFAAAAIBAJ&pg=6087%2C2231066 August 29, 1903 San Jose Evening News] gives details of their sales in the season.
-[http://vasonabranch.blogspot.com/2011/05/earl-fruit-company.html Capsule history]
-[http://digitalassets.lib.berkeley.edu/roho/ucb/text/digiorgio_family__w.pdf Interview with DiGiorgio family]
 [[Category:Bassett Street San Jose]]
 [[Category:Dried Fruit Packer]]
 [[Category:Fresh Fruit Packer]]

Difference between revisions of "Earl Fruit Company"

Latest revision as of 17:56, 17 January 2017

Contents

Earl Fruit and Armour

Locations

Photos

References

Navigation menu

Search